For me it depends on what you mean by "earthlike". If i want something very much like Earth, a terra with multicellular life on land, around an K, G or F main sequence star, and not being tidally locked to said star. If i want something not that earthlike, i just search for a terra, and for in-between, somewhere between the previous two scenarios.
And i often use atmosphere restrictions and disable tidally locked planets, and occasionally use other restrictions.
Space is too big to understand, so do not try to understand.